It is extremely frustrating to be told time after time that I would be a fantastic catch… for someone else. To have guys exclaim, in reference to something I do or say, “I wish I had a girlfriend like that!”
I know they’re all sincere. And there’s absolutely nothing wrong with them saying it. Every time a guy says that I take it as the compliment it is. My qualm is not with the guys who are saying such things. But when I step back and look at the whole picture, at the sheer number of times I have been in that situation (I can’t even count them, but it must be in the hundreds), and compare that to the number of times I have had a guy show legitimate interest in me (once… 5 years ago… and he lived 1500 miles away the entire time), it’s hard to not be discouraged. It’s hard to look at that and not think “there must be something intrinsically wrong with me”, to wonder what it is that makes me a “great catch for someone else” but never truly a catch for anyone at all.
There’s this girl I knew a while ago. She’s not what I would call unattractive, but quite honestly she doesn’t have anything looks-wise on me (nor do I on her; we’re in the same boat as far as fitting into the Societal Standard for Attractiveness). And I am not meaning to build myself up or put her down, but the truth is I have been told by several people that they think I have a more attractive personality than she does. So the question is: Why did she seem to get guy after guy while I’ve sat dateless for 5 years? She’s getting married now, and I’ve barely even ever had a boyfriend.
What is this mental block guys have? I once sat next to a guy who (at the time) I was very interested in while he explained to another guy what a relationship should look like, and what traits to look for in a girlfriend. Everything he said applied to me, and yet at the time he was chasing after some girl that didn’t fit any of them at all. But she was thin and “pretty” and I don’t know what, but I guess there was something that made her oh-so-appealing, even though everyone could see it was going nowhere.
And that story repeats itself. I can’t tell you how many of my male friends I’ve watched go after girls that are horrible fits for them but are “appealing” in some other way. How many times I’ve been interested in a guy only to watch him fall in love with my best friend or the girl across the hall or some chick he’s never even talked to.
I guess I just have to keep hoping that at some point the cycle will be broken, and by some miracle a guy will actually take interest in me and have the nerve to do something about it. I suppose I should say something about how I’m content being single and am being patient and waiting on God to bring the right man in at the right time and blah blah blah blah BLAH. It’s all true, but it’s so cliché. So I guess I’ll end with a poem I wrote not too long ago:
The Girl Does Not Turn Heads
I am not a girl who inspires poetry or song
With a glimpse of my (imperfect) smile
Or a toss of my (non-descript) hair.
(You wouldn’t catch me dead in a bikini.)
I don’t giggle.
I don’t scream when the lights go out
or when I get wet,
and I’d rather go hiking than to a spa.
(Tanning is just a side-effect of doing things.)
But I hope you know I’d drive all night to see you.
I’d make your favorite food, just because.
I’d climb a tree, or watch a movie,
or help you set things on fire.
I’d sit and listen to your passions,
and jump in to make them reality.
I’d smile just because you walked into the room,
and love our silences as much as our laughter.
And I guess I already do all of that,
but I don’t suppose you’ve ever really noticed.
So I’ll watch you chase the pretty ones,
and give you advice,
and comfort you every time they let you down.
And we’ll just be friends, like we’ve always been.
And you’ll never be the wiser.